Butterfinger Ice Cream

When it comes to indulgent frozen treats, few desserts can compete with the creamy, delightful richness of homemade ice cream. Butterfinger Ice Cream, in particular, stands out as a unique flavor experience because of its delicious balance of creaminess and crunchy textures. Made with decadent ingredients that meld together to create a rich, buttery taste, it captures the essence of the beloved Butterfinger candy bars that many have grown to love. The smooth creamy base interspersed with crunchy Butterfinger pieces offers a delightful contrast that is sure to please any sweet tooth.

this recipe

What You’ll Need for Butterfinger Ice Cream

To craft this irresistible frozen treat, gather the following ingredients. Each plays a crucial role in developing the flavor and texture that make Butterfinger Ice Cream an enchanting experience.

Complete Ingredients List

• 1 pint heavy cream
• 1 (12 oz) can evaporated milk
• 1 (14 oz) can sweetened condensed milk
• 4 cups whole milk
• 1 (3.4 oz) box vanilla instant pudding
• 3/4 cup sugar
• 4 tablespoons vanilla extract
• 5 (1.9-ounce) Butterfinger bars, crushed

Ingredient Substitutions & Alternatives

If you’re looking to modify the recipe for specific dietary needs or preferences, here are some alternatives:

• Dairy-Free: Swap the heavy cream, whole milk, and evaporated milk for coconut cream and a dairy-free milk like almond milk or oat milk. Make sure your condensed milk is dairy-free as well.
• Gluten-Free: Butterfinger bars contain gluten, so explore gluten-free snack bars or make your own homemade version to use in your ice cream.
• Sugar-Free: Use sugar substitutes like Stevia or erythritol for those who want to reduce their sugar intake. Ensure the Butterfinger bars you choose are sugar-free.
• Vegan Version: While crafting a completely vegan Butterfinger is challenging, using dairy-free substitutes as mentioned above can work well.

For flavor creativity, consider adding chocolate fudge swirls or peanut butter swirls for that additional textural and flavor depth.

How to Make Butterfinger Ice Cream

Now that you’ve assembled your ingredients, it’s time to get creative in the kitchen and whip up some Butterfinger Ice Cream! Follow these detailed steps to achieve that perfect creamy texture infused with satisfying crunch.

Step 1: Combine the Base

In a large mixing bowl, whisk together the heavy cream, evaporated milk, sweetened condensed milk, and whole milk. These dairy components are essential for creating a rich and creamy base. Make sure they’re well-combined to achieve a smooth mixture.

Step 2: Add the Sweetness

Next, add the instant vanilla pudding mix and sugar to the milk blend. This step is crucial as the pudding mix will help thicken the ice cream while adding vanilla flavor. Whisk consistently until everything is thoroughly blended, and there are no lumps.

Step 3: Infuse with Flavor

Pour in the vanilla extract and mix until well incorporated. Vanilla enhances the overall flavor profile of your ice cream, making it rich and aromatic.

Step 4: Chill the Mixture

Cover the bowl with plastic wrap or a lid and place it in the refrigerator for about 2-3 hours. Chilling the mixture ensures a quick churn and a smoother texture once it freezes.

Step 5: Churn the Ice Cream

Once your batter is cold, pour it into your ice cream maker. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for churning. Typically, it can take about 20-25 minutes for the mixture to reach a soft-serve consistency.

Step 6: Add the Butterfinger Pieces

In the last 5 minutes of churning, be sure to add in the crushed Butterfinger bars. This step not only incorporates their flavor but also gives you that crunchy texture that’s signature to Butterfinger Ice Cream.

Step 7: Serve or Store

Once churning is complete, you can serve the ice cream immediately for a soft-serve texture, or transfer it to an airtight container to freeze for an additional two hours to firm it up.

Serving Suggestions for Butterfinger Ice Cream

How to Serve Butterfinger Ice Cream

Butterfinger Ice Cream is best served chilled, so make sure to keep it in the freezer until you’re ready to enjoy. For the ideal serving experience, consider scooping generous portions into chilled bowls or waffle cones for an extra layer of decadence.

Plating or Cutting Tips

For enhanced presentation, drizzle some chocolate syrup or caramel sauce over the top of the ice cream. Garnish with a few Butterfinger chunks for an appetizing finish. If you’re serving it in cups, top with whipped cream for that dreamy touch!

Perfect Pairings & Toppings

To enhance your Butterfinger Ice Cream experience even more, consider topping it with:

• Whipped cream
• Chocolate syrup or fudge
• Extra crushed Butterfinger or other candy bar pieces
• Nuts such as almonds or peanuts for an added crunch
• Fresh fruit like bananas or strawberries for a refreshing twist

Storing & Preserving Butterfinger Ice Cream

Best Storage Methods

Storing your Butterfinger Ice Cream properly will ensure it remains fresh and enjoyable. For the best results, transfer the ice cream to an airtight container and freeze it. It can last up to 2-3 weeks in the freezer, but it’s so delicious it’s unlikely to survive that long!

Reheating or Freezing Tips

If your ice cream becomes too hard after freezing, let it sit at room temperature for a few minutes before scooping it out. This will help soften it slightly, allowing for easier serving. Avoid reheating in the microwave, as the texture can be compromised.

Tips for Perfect Butterfinger Ice Cream Every Time

Avoid These Common Mistakes

• Skipping the Chill Step: Make sure to chill the mixture sufficiently. If the base is warm going into the ice cream maker, it won’t churn properly.
• Not Using an Ice Cream Maker: Using an ice cream maker is essential to achieve the right consistency. Trying to freeze the mixture in a container without churning will lead to ice crystals forming.
• Over-churning: Once your ice cream reaches soft-serve consistency, stop the churning process! Over-churning can lead to a grainy texture.

Helpful Tricks for Success

• Use Quality Ingredients: The better the ingredients you use, the more delightful the outcome. Opt for organic cream and whole milk if possible for that extra richness.
• Keep it Cold: Try to minimize the amount of time your mixture is out of the fridge. Quick handling will prevent it from warming up.
• Customize Your Ice Cream: Don’t hesitate to experiment! Adjust the vanilla flavor, or try candy-crushing variations like Reese’s or Snickers bars.

Fun Variations of Butterfinger Ice Cream

Flavor Variations or Recipe Twists

Butterfinger Ice Cream isn’t limited to just the classic flavor. Here are some fun twists to consider:

• Chocolate Lovers: Incorporate chocolate ice cream base instead of vanilla and swirl in chocolate fudge with Butterfinger pieces.
• Nutty Crunch: Add crushed peanuts or almond pieces into the ice cream mix for added richness and flavor.
• Minty Fresh: Consider adding mint extract to create a mint-chocolate Butterfinger combo, perfect for those who love the classic mint chocolate chip taste.

Dietary-Friendly Adjustments

If you have dietary restrictions, here’s how you might alter the Butterfinger Ice Cream recipe:

• Keto-Friendly: Utilize heavy cream, almond milk, and sugar substitutes diligently to keep the carb count low without compromising taste.
• Sugar-Free: Look for sugar-free Butterfinger alternatives and use sugar-less sweeteners for the base.

FAQs

What If My Butterfinger Ice Cream Doesn’t Turn Out Right?

If your ice cream turns out too icy, it may not have been mixed or churned sufficiently, or the base might have been too warm. To correct a runny mixture, consider allowing it to churn longer in the machine, or possibly adding more thickening agents like additional pudding mix.

Can I Prepare This in Advance?

Absolutely! You can prepare your Butterfinger Ice Cream base a day in advance. Just be sure to keep it in the refrigerator* and churn it when you’re ready to enjoy. It also stores well in the freezer, making it an excellent option for gathering or parties.

What Ingredients Can I Swap?

Ingredient swaps can generally be made depending on dietary preferences. For instance, you can replace heavy cream with coconut cream for a dairy-free version, or use different candy bars if Butterfinger isn’t available to you.

Print